Bản án số 77/2024/DS-PT ngày 25/09/2024 của TAND tỉnh Phú Thọ về tranh chấp đất đai

  • Thuộc tính
  • Nội dung
  • VB gốc
  • VB liên quan
  • Lược đồ
  • Đính chính
  • Án lệ
  • BA/QĐ cùng nội dung
  • Tải về
Tải văn bản
Báo lỗi
  • Gửi liên kết tới Email
  • Chia sẻ:
  • Chế độ xem: Sáng | Tối
  • Thay đổi cỡ chữ:
    17

Thuộc tính Bản án 77/2024/DS-PT

Tên Bản án: Bản án số 77/2024/DS-PT ngày 25/09/2024 của TAND tỉnh Phú Thọ về tranh chấp đất đai
Quan hệ pháp luật: Tranh chấp đất đai
Cấp xét xử: Phúc thẩm
Tòa án xét xử: TAND tỉnh Phú Thọ
Số hiệu: 77/2024/DS-PT
Loại văn bản: Bản án
Ngày ban hành: 25/09/2024
Lĩnh vực: Dân sự
Áp dụng án lệ:
Đã biết

Quý khách vui lòng Đăng nhập tài khoản để xem áp dụng án lệ. Nếu chưa có tài khoản, Quý khách vui lòng đăng ký tại đây!

Đính chính:
Đã biết

Quý khách vui lòng Đăng nhập tài khoản để xem đính chính. Nếu chưa có tài khoản, Quý khách vui lòng đăng ký tại đây!

Thông tin về vụ/việc: Tranh chấp hợp đồng quyền sử dụng đất
Tóm tắt Bản án

Nội dung tóm tắt đang được cập nhật, Quý khách vui lòng quay lại sau!

Tải văn bản

1
TOÀ ÁN NHÂN DÂN CỘNG HOÀ XÃ HỘI CH NGHĨA VIÊT NAM
TỈNH PHÚ THỌĐộc lp-T do-Hạnh phúc
B:77/2024/DS-PT
-9-2024
phng
quyn s d
NHÂN DANH
C CỘNG HOÀ XÃ HỘI CH NGHĨA VIỆT NAM
TOÀ ÁN NHÂN DÂN TỈNH PHÚ THỌ
-Thành phần Hội đồng xét xử phúc thm gồm có:
Thẩm phán-Ch to phiên t
Các thẩm phán: ng
 t
- Thư phiên toà: -
Th.
-Đại din Vin kim sát nhân dân tỉnh Phú Thọtham gia phiên tòa
Phm Ngc Hoa- Ki
i tr s  ti
         th  : 62/2024/TLPT -  
  p quyn s d m
s 04/2024/DS-n Tam
 b 
Theo Quy         m s-
           -PT
nh m l:
Nguyên đơn: Anh Nguy ng Th T, sinh
i din theo y quyn ca anh L: Ch ng Th Tu
a ch: n C, tt
B đơn:  T1
a ch: n T, t.
i bo v quyT1Nguyc H -
Lu c  -  nh Pa ch:SN A, t B, khu T,
ng T,  V, tt
Ngƣời có quyền lợi, nghĩa vụ liên quan:  ng Th T2  
a ch: n T, t.Vng mt
Ngƣời tham gia t tụng khác:
 
2

a ch: n T, t.
Nguy
a ch: n T, t.
u vng mt.
NI DUNG V ÁN:
Ti kii khai cNguy
ng Th Tn gc quyn s dt v chp
vT1 chL1H1. V chL1H1
y chng nhn quyn s dt s CM 061843 c
ng chuy t ch
nhy chng nhn quyn s d ch
 cha) v dit nhn chuyng ca
v ch  L1 ng di   p cho v ch 
L1v th
 cha ca v chL1H102 tht
na: 01 thT4theo giy chng nhn quyn s t s CM
061140 c chng chuyng quyn
s d t chy
chng nhn quyn s d cha v
ch L1H1   ch  L1chuyng sang cho v
ch ch ng Th Tuyt .Do vn
 ch T1T2ng chuyng quyn s
dng nht gia v chL1, v chng T1 ch
v chT1vi v ch t 
v chc cp giy chng nhn quyn s d
p chung c  ch
  y t   t     v ch   c UBND
huyn Tcp giy chng nhn quyn s dt s CT 329
thuc tha s 178, t b s 5, di
2

V), huyn T, t(ding ca 03 th chng
 
t v ch d
chp t  chT1n
t ca v chu my
sut theo chi   t. V ch    i v  T1 
T1 chn 
 chT1lp li mt bng tr li
3
quyn s dt cho v chn di ch
cL1H1thuc tha 198, t b s T3
T1; Thng chuyng quyn s dt do thng nht
gia v chL1, v chT1 chu theo mng
Quc l  mng Quc l 
n quyn s dt cho v chy chng nhn quyn
s dt s CT 329924 c
2

100m
2
t , 427m
2
t trc tha s 178, t b s 05.Cm
T1c thc him quyn s dt ca v chng
 
a b n c
t ci th
y t  chng minh sau.
V ch  vit ca v ch ch 
     ng Th T2trong h ng chuy ng quyn s
dn gn lin vt lia v ch
chng anh L, ch T vi a v ch
V ch y t gm:
-n  ngh tch tha t, hp thc t ngy 04/9/2019.
-n  ngh cp li, cp i giy chng nhn quyn s d 
04/9/2019.
-n ng k bin ng vt n gn lin v
i vi t khai thu TNCN ch m  
V ch    chng anh L      
n vi nhau vvi.
 
trin qu t huyn T th 
Tha t theo giy chng nhn quyn s dt s CM 061140 cp ngy
24/5/2018 ca v chng ng L1v bH1pha gip nhng T4, vic vchng ng
L1chuyn nhng cho v chng anh L  c mc,tranh ch   
quyn ca v chL1n v ch
Tip gip tha t ca v chng ng L1ghi trn l 3m mt ng (theo
Bin bn tho thun ngy 10/5/2018) l ca v chng ti bn cho ng P
P L1 c ghi nhn t n tho thu
 vit bng ghi nha
L1Png
chuyng quyn s d chng
L1chuyng cho v chng anh Lng
4
chuyn di chng anh L(th hin ti Hng chuyn
ng quyn s dn gn lin v4/9/2019).
Trong h chiu m tit ca
v chL1ghi  dit
   
sau ch i 38m. Quyn s dL1
P.
Tha t theo giy chng nhn quyn s dt s CM 061843 cp ngy
24/8/2018 pha gip nhng T3: V h s v chng ng L1cgiy chng nhn
quyn s dt ti khng thc mc g nn theo ti liu chuyn nhng quyn s
dt gia v chng ng L1vi v chT3
c ma vchT3 chL1
 2m mng c th hi 
 T3    t th         t
i v chng anh Lp theo mt
         nh hin tr   
18/01/2024. Hi     i li v  T3  v ch 
L1 chL1c cp giy chng nhn quyn s
d cung c  chT3a

n l ng Th T2
T1 ch  ng Th T2trong Hngchuyng
quyn s dng    n gn lin v       h
c tranh cht gia v chng anh Lvi
T1: T i v chng anh L
 c
ngh t c vi
ngh i quyt vng m
Ngƣời tham gia t tụng khác trình bày:
 : Vi chL1H1 tc chuyn
ng quyn s dt theo giy chng nhn quyn s dt s CM 061843
 T1 
T1 tc chuyng quyn s d
 u kin thc mc g ch
L1c cp giy chng nhn quyn s dt s 
chL1c chuyt c
T1n pht cT1 ngh 
5
n tha thun v vic chuyng quyn
s d
 ng nh
thuc quyn s dng cL1T1
L1    i nhau v tranh chp trong ni dung ghi nh  
L1v ghi nhn bng giy t L1chuyng cho ai
nt vic v chng anh L Tkhi kii vT1
 ngh u t ngh c vng mt
trong tt c .
Tr:V li khai cP
c m
V li khai cT1  li khai 02 tht:
Tht mang giy chng nhn quyn s dng t s CM061140 c
 c mt
tip theo 03m (ti    t s      ch 
chuyng cho v chng anh La v chT1, v chng
 chng anh Lng nh   cho
ching tht ghi s giy chng nhn quyn s d
v chT1ng chuyng quyn s dng
t gia v ch  T1vi v chng anh L   t theo theo giy
chng nhn quyn s dt s CM 061843 ct
 cha v chT3, v mc gi chT3
p giy chng nhn quyn s dt cho v ch
T1cho rT3 02m mng cT1
Vic v H1c gi
nh kn vic kin gia v chng anh LvT1n
   H1 ngh ng triu t  ngh c vng mt
trong tt c .
Ti Bản án dân sự thẩm s04/2024/DS-23/4-2024
sa cha, b sung Bca, t 
  n 1 - u 8, Khon 1,2 -   u 115, 164, 169,
500,501, 502,503 B lu; Khon 1- u 147 B lut t tu
u 170 Lu- u 12,Ngh quyt 326/2016/UBTVQH14
 a   ng v Quc H  nh v mc thu, min,
gim, thu, np, qu d 
X: Chp nhu khi kin ca anh Nguy ng Th
Ti v .
6
 n quyn s d t ca anh Nguy   ch ng Th
Ttheo giy chng nhn quyn s dt, quyn s h n
lin vt s CT 329924 do UBND huyn Tc

2
t , 427m
2
t trc tha s 178,
t b s  ti giy chng nhn quyn s d
n trng th
  n qu t huyn Ttheo ch gi    
theo).
Bu ng   phi tr li quyn s d t cho v chng anh
Nguy ng Th Ttheo ch gii: 3,4,5,6, 
n trng thn s d
trin qu t huyn T
Bu chm dt mm quyn s dt
a v chng anh Nguy ng Th T.
B  quy
  i n
thu th      ng c c       
quandn vii thc t  d
phm quyng ni dung c th 
 cm).
 gh  t  ng hy Bn
n h  li theo th t m
bo quy
Tại phiên tòaphúc thẩmi bo v quy
  ngh  i.
L ngh gi a cm.
i din Vin ki n v vi
t t ti quyt v a Thng
c cht ca nhi tham gia t
t k t khi th  c thm H ngh
u thc hinh ca B lut t t.
u v m ni dung v  khou 308 B lut t tng
.
p nh , gi 
m s04/2024/DS-S23-4-2024ca.
NHẬN ĐỊNH CA TÒA ÁN:
  
 nhnh:
7
[1] V t tng:
V  n lu
hp l.
V s t c: B n li
  vng mt. Hng tip t 
 u 296 B lut t t.
[2]  n .
Ngun gcgiy chng nhn quyn s d t s CT 329924 c 

2

2
t , 427m
2
t tr
  c tha s 178, t b  s 05 ca v chng anh L  Tnhn
chuyng ca v chNguy Th Lan H2a ch
n T, t03 thtgm:
+ Tha th nht:Nhn chuyng ca v chL1H201 tha
T4) theo giy chng nhn quyn s t cL1
H2s CM 061140 c chng anh L Tng
chuyng quyn s d t chng
anh L, ch Ty chng nhn quyn s dt chung ca v
chng anh L Ts CT 329924 c
tranhchp.
+ Tha th hai: Nhn chuyng tht tip ca v chL1H2:
Th chL1chuyng cho v
chng anh L Ty chng nhn quyn s dt v
ng Th Tuyt .Do vT1T2
thun thng nhy chng nhn quyn s d 
t  chng anh L T chT1T2
y t    chng anh L T. V chng anh L
Ty chng nhn quyn s dt ca v chng anh ch s
CT 329924 cc tha s 178, t b s 5, di
2
khu 2 n T, t.Th
chp v chiu mng Quc l 
chng anh LT1L1u tha nhp v chi
ca tht giT1 chng anh L.
Theo v chng anh L: Khi nhn giy chng nhn quyn s dt ca v
chL1do quyn s dt v chT1
chL1, v chT1 chng anh Lu thng nht: V ch
T1 chng anh Lng chuyng quyn s dt t v chng
T1trc tip sang v chng anh L mng quc l
 tha thun gi chT1i v chng
8
anh Lng chuyng quyn s dn gn lin vt

T1tha nh chuyv chng anh ch Lut T
 chuyng 35m chi mng quc l 
T1n ch k  
ng Th T2a v chT1T2n chuy
a anh Nguyng Th T 
u chng c m thu th  nh:
BT2(v cT1) tha nhng chuyn
ng quyn s d T2
chi v chng anh Lnh giy chng nhn quyn s dt ca ai
n s dt ghi dip vi
chia th hin tr
   p vi li khai c  L1  ch L1chuyn
ng cho v chng anh La v chng T1, v chL1
v chng anh Lng nh chi   cho
chibng tht ghi s  chT1
ng chuyng quyn s dt gia v chT1vi v
chng anh L  nh v chng anh Lnhn chuyn
ng thi chiu mng Quc l 
mng Quc l 32 chng anh L
y, php gia v chng anh LT1a v chng
anh Lc nhn chuyng ht ca v ch
L1th     t s CM 061843 c    
Nguy Th Lan H2chuyng cho v chng anh L, ch T(nay
v chng anh L   y chng nhn quyn s d t ca v
chng anh Ltheo giy chng nhn quyn s d t s CT 329924 c 
03/10/2019). Quyn s dp giT1 chng anh L,
c th tranh chp v chiu ngang mng Quc l 
t mng quc l v ha thn ca v chng anh
L:Vic nhn chuyng quyn s dng tha v chL1theo
u mng Quc l u
t ca nhT3 chng anh
Lmua ca v chL1ng do v chng T1i v chng
anh L T1cho rng: Trong chiu
rng thng Quc l C ha
T1T3ng c di chL1
v chL1mi chuyng cho v chng anh L  a
9
   nh:
BT2ng s hu quyn s dT2v
p vy chng nhn quyn s d
n s d chng anh La v
chng anh LT3 nh vic v ch chL1 tc
chuyng quyn s dt theo gi  n
T1 T1 tc chuyng
quyn s d u kin
thc m chL1c cp giy chng nhn quyn s dt
s  chL1c chuy
t cT1n pht cT1.Mt
 L1nh th t theo giy chng nhn quyn s d t s CM
061843 c chn chuyng
ca v chT3, v mc gii v chL1v chT3
p giy chng nhn quyn s dt cho v chL1
T1cho rnT3ng cT1cho v ch
. Do vy, quyn s d chL1nhn chuyng
ca v ch T3 T1y v
chL1c cp giy chng nhn quyn s dt s 
 vic chuyng quyn s d t gia v ch
T3vi v ch  L1     ch  L1 n chuyn
ngcho v chng anh L   t. Di     chng anh
Lnhn chuyng ca v chL1ng diy chng
nhn quyn s dp cho v chL1ghi 
LiT2T3 L1 p vi Hng chuyn
nhng quyn s dn gn lin vc l
gia v chT3vi v chL1. Theo hT1nh
n ch   
T1p v hin trng theo h ng th
T1u, chng c ng
Quc l Cc quyn s dng cT1.
T nh   nh: Vic v chng anh
L  Tnhn chuy ng quyn s d t ca v ch  L1 
H2a theo giy chng nhn quyn s dt s CM
061140 ca theo giy chng nhn quyn s dt s
CM 061843 ca v chT1T2(theo hng
chuyng quyn s dn gn lin vt l
t. V chng anh L Tp chung y chng
10
nhn quyn s d t s CT 329924 c      
527m
2

2
t , 427m
2
t trc tha s 178,
t b s  theo giy chng nhn quyn s d 
hp v n l
n anh ch Lut Tn s hu h quyn s
d ti Giy chng nhn quyn s dt s CT 329924
cn trng tht s 178, t b s
 gi
 p. ViT1t (theo ch gic
       n chim quyn s d t ca v
chng anh Lch Tm buT1phi tr li quyn s dng
 chng anh L T.
Do anh Lch TT1phc lt ban
 cp x p.
Ti bo v quyT1 ngh
 chp nhn.
T nh 
  chp nh , cn gi ngm
c.
m ca Luo v quy 
T1c chp nhn.
 ngh ca Vin kic chp nhn.
[3] V  c chp nhn
T1 i Cao tui chm.
[4] a Bth
, H i quyt.
Vì các lẽ trên:
QUYẾT ĐỊNH:
 khou 308B lut t t;
 .
Gi  m s 04/2024/DS-23/4/2024ca
, t.
    u 8, Kho    u 115, 164, 169,
500,501, 502,503 B lu; Khou 147 B lut t tu
  u 170 Lu     u 12, kho  u 29Ngh quyt
30/12/2016 ca ng v Quc Hnh
v mc thu, min, gim, thu, np, qu d 
11
X: Chp nhu khi kin ca anh Nguy ng Th
Ti v .
 n quyn s d t ca anh Nguy    ng Th
Ttheo giy chng nhn quyn s dt, quyn s h n
lin vt s CT 329924 do UBND huyn Tc
527m
2

2
t , 427m
2
t trc tha s 178,
t b s  ti giy chng nhn quyn s d
n trng th
  n qu t huyn Ttheo ch gi    
theo).
Bu    phi tr li quyn s d t cho v chng anh
Nguy ng Th Ttheo ch gii: 3,4,5,6,11,12,9,1 
n trng thn s d
trin qu t huyn T
Bu chm dt mm quyn s dt
a v chng anh Nguy ng Th T.
ng hp Bnh tu 2 Lu
 i ph 
quyn tha thu nguy
hoc b ng ch nh t Lu
; thi hic thc hinh tu 30 Lut thi
.
V   c chp
nhT1i cao tui ch m.
Phn quynh ca B  
hiu l t thm h.
Bu lt ngay k t 
Nơi nhận:
- VKSND t;
- VKSND huy
- TAND huy
- Chi cc THADS huy
- ;
- ;
- 
T/M HỘI ĐỒNG XÉT XỬ PHÚC THẨM
Thẩm phán - Ch tọa phiên tòa
Phạm Văn Toàn
12
C
13
TÒA ÁN NHÂN DÂN
HUYỆN PHÙ NINH
TỈNH PHÚ TH
__________________
B: 01/2024/DS-ST
-01-2024
  p quyn s dng

ỘNG HÒA XÃ HỘI CHỦ NGHĨA VIỆT NAM
Độc lp - T do - Hnh Phúc
______________________________________________________
NHÂN DANH
C CỘNG HÒA XÃ HỘI CH NGHĨA VIỆT NAM
TÒA ÁN NHÂN DÂN HUYỆN PHÙ NINH, TỈNH PHÚ THỌ
- Thành phần Hội đồng xét xử thẩm gm có:
Thẩm phán - Ch tòa phiên tòa:
Các Hội thẩm nhân dân:
n Th Hoa
n Th Kim Hoa
- Thư phiên tòa:Nguyn Ngc P1 n
.
- Đại din Vin kiểm sát nhân dân huyện Phù Ninh, tỉnh Phú Thọtham
gia phiên tòa: Nguy- Ki
i tr s 
t ti    35/2020/TLST-
       vic "Tranh chp quyn s d  
Quy vic m : 14/2024/TB-

Nguyên đơn:  Trn Th T5     i: Khu F, th trn P,
huyn P, tt;
B đơn:
Nguy vng mt.
L Th H4 vng mt.
i: n T, t.
Khut Th H5
i: n P, t
i din theo y quyn: Anh Nguyn Quang S
14
ti: n P, tt
4. Anh Nguyn Quang Si: n P, tnh
t
Người có quyền lợi, nghĩa vụ liên quan:
1. Ch ng Kim T7,  1981; : S ng B,
qu ii din theo y quyTrn Th T5, sinh
i: Khu F, th trn P, huyn P, t;
2. Anh ng Quang H6, 1983; : Khu F, th trn P, huyn P,
ti din theo y quyTrn Th T5
ti: Khu F, th trn P, huyn P, t;
3. Ch Nguyn Th N,  1990; : n P, tnh
i din theo y quyn: Anh Nguyn Quang S, sinh 
i: Khu 8, , 

, 
Nguyn Quyt T8, 1954; : T ng G,
 V, t vng mt.
    ,  1960 
ng Th Hng P2, 
1970; : T D, ph  V, t; 



.
6. Trn Th T9i: Khu E, th trn P, huyn P, tnh
 vng mt
7. Anh Nguyi: n P, tnh
 vng mt.
8. , huyn P, ti din theo y
quyTrn Trung K- 


 vng mt;
9. n P, ta din theo y quyn:
Nguyn Ngc Q - 
x vng mt
Khut Ngc T10(




 

1990 2003); : n P, t
x vng mt
  Nguy  (


ng y  
 1990-
1999), 1950; : n P, t-
x vng mt.
12. Trn Mnh C1(

ch 
1992-1999),
1949, : n P, t vng
mt.
13. phn Da ch: yn H, ti
i diTrc H7 vng mt.
14. Ch Nguyn Th L3a ch: n P, tnh
 vng mt.
NI DUNG V ÁN:
15
Nguyên đơn ba
̀
Trn Th T5trnh bày:
18/10/1993,  Nguyn Th C2(
Nguyn Quang P3, 
2002) 01 



 120m2
(

90m2 

30m2 
), 2 
6m, 
20m. 

 2,  

 P3, 
B(

Q, phP3. Di





 152-1, 

 36 

101,

51 n P, t


 , 


C2UBND huyn P(nay
huyn P) 
C2
445 1987 360m2 
.
C2

Bn di
.








Trn Th T9

. 




18/10/1993 Nguyn Th C2, 




22/12/1993, 


18/12/1993, 












, 








 18/10/1993, 


15/11/1993, 


 596/-
25/02/1994,

 ...  T9




.




 




, 


, 


. 
1994 a thun vH5i ph
C2 ly phn dit thuc tha 80-2, t b s 36 (ph
t mua cC2. Nay theo b t phn ca
th b s H5n 
 t9 


 S

 C2i ly
120m2 thuc tht 80- ti th. Sau khi






T9t, 







 i vi pht mua cuC2u
thuc tha 152-c cp giy chng nhn quyn s d
  ng l 





  UBND huyn P





 P3 H5 26/12/2001 




1.336m2, 










C2.
P3, H5


 1 


 200m2
(100m2 

100m2 
) 




Nguyn
Quyt T8v 20.000.000 (
 ).  14/8/2003 UBND
huyn P




 T8.  P3,
H5

 T8120m2 
C2





16
T8




 
ng Th Hng P2
 100.000.000(

) 
UBND huyn P





, 
P214/8/2017.
, P2 


   L Th H4

218.000.000 (



  T11,  H4

 UBND huyn P


11/10/2017. 
, 
 T11, H401 4,









.
 T11, H4SH5120m2 
thuc tha 152-1, 

36 (Nay theo b 

101, 
 51) n P, t 
C2.
T u khi ki ngh T11, H4,
SH5120m2 c tha 152-1, 

36 (Nay theo
b 
101, 
51) n
P, t C2 

. N 
120m2 c tha 152-1, 

36 (Nay
theo b 
101, 
 51) khu 
huyn P, t C2i tr  120m2 c
tha 80-2, 

 36 (Nay theo b t phn
thuc 
95 96, 
51) n P, t.
B đơn:
Ông Nguyễn Văn T6và bà L Th H4thng nhấttrnh bày:





 101, 

 51, 


212,8m2 (

100m2 
, 112,8m2 ) khu
n P, tNguyn Th Hng P4
21/8/2017 UBND huyn P




11/10/2017.







 , P4



, P4





 






 . 




,  P4




 T8 T8




 . 
















. 


01
4   



cho anh S
 .  , 


anh S
H5.






T5




, 



 , 










C2, T9

P3, H5. 










17




, 



.
 , 







.

S, T9








, 
. 










. 







, 
, 





, 









. 

.
Khut Th H5, do anh Slà đại din theo y quyn, anh Nguyn Quang
Sđều thống nhất trnh bày:



T5







P3, H5
 1976.  1987 


 P3, H5 , 





.
10P3
UBND huyn P

458/

 360m2 







. 
26/12/2001, UBND huyn P



 P3,
H5152-1, 
36, 

1.336m2 (

300m2


1.36m2 
).
P3, H5 200m2 (100m2 
100m2 
T8, 




1.136m2 (


200m2 

930m2 
). 10/5/2006, UBND huyn P






H5 2002P3.
20/10/2010, H5

100m2 (

65m2 
35m2 
Nguyn Quang H8th trn P anh S519m2

. P3 517m2 (

135m2 

582m2 

).
12/12/2014, 


  H5

UBND huyn P





 138179, 
 00542, 





 96, 

 51, 

575,3m2 (

135m2 

440,3m2  ), 

.
 P3, H5





, 











 , 

 

T5, 



, 





 P3, H5
.
 T5

H5

 T8







 T801 4, ba









 P3, H5








Thy cung c. 

Thy cung c



C2 T5
18
 C2








(C2i n P
anh Nguy). 





C2
P3
11/10/1987.
n chuyt cng P3H5T8c UBND
huyn Pc 

ng l, P4, P4c cp
 v
T6, H4
UBND huyn
P.  T6, H9, 

SH5cho  phn D ng may
t vng. T5cho r




S.
i vu khi kin c chp nh
P3H5s dt hc cp giy chng nhn quyn s
dng cho nhii. Su khi
T5cho rT9nhn chuyng cC2T9
T5 dng hay qui kia
m bt h

C2ti v T5hi
khi ki  m  hin
C2t ti khu vc C2Nguy
Mtha nhC2t ti khu v




C2

T9


T9hin nay trc tham gia t tng tng t h 
chuyng giT9C2u khut tt. BT10
 h
i ch vi giy t  viNguyn Th C2u
t. H5, anh S, ch Nn t.
Người có quyn li nghĩa vụ liên quan:
ChịĐặng Kim T7và anh Đặng Quang H6, do bà T5là đi din theo y quyn
trnh bày: Thng nhT5 ngh 
p nhu cT5c lp.
Ch Nguyn Th N, do anh Slà đại din theo y quyền trnh bày: Thng nht
vi lời trnh bày của anh Snhư trên.  ngh i kin cT5.
c lp.
Anh Nguyễn Văn Mtrnh bày:
t cNguyn Th C2C2
NguyKhut Th H5. M 
ng vc bit m t
ti n Ptht ti 
P, huyn Phay khu vt. Pht
m anh n g la s 180, t b s 36, din
t n. M 
19
th c UBND huyn Pcp giy chng
nhn quyn s d
ao ch 
Anh kh  viNguyn Th C2




 18/10/1993; 









 18/10/1993; 



 18/12/1993;











 18/12/1993 do
T5xui ch  vit ca m anh.
i vu khi kin cT5t tranh chp
c chuyng qua nhic UBND huyn cp
giy chng nhn quyn s dt. Vic gii quyt v n anh
 ngh c l
 vng mt.
Ông Nguyễn Quyết T8trnh bày:
02/7/2003, H5




 200m2 (100m2


100m2 
) 152-1 khu N ln P, t
Th

20.000.000 (
 ).  14/8/2003 UBND
huyn P




.
N27/3/2014, 






 
ng Th Hng P2
 100.000.000(

) 
UBND huyn P





, 
P2.










H5
01 4, 






 P5, H5. Sau
, P2




.

T5

 T6, H9
 










H5


, P2. 
, 



, 













, 
, 

; 


, phi








.
Ông Ngô Văn Đvà bà Nguyn Th Hng P4trnh bày:
 27/3/2014        nh P T8




 152-1, 

 36, 


200m2(100m2 
, 100m2 
) 


100.000.000(


). 


 T8





 .






 2017







 . UBND huyn P







 14/8/2017 






101, 

 51, 

212,8m2. 











20








T8. 









21/8/2017 





).
T6, H9







.  T5












 T8, 


 . 



, 
 , 


. 









, 
, 

, .
Trn Th T9trnh bày: T5ng n
i quan h T5 ng Kim
L4ng chuyng quyn s dt
    y t   nh t ca C2. Vi     
T5 tT5
 gC2t th 
T10C1K1. Ch  vit c
y chuyt th  n kim tra
c v vi khai thu thu nh
18/12/1993; t khai np l c b  i ch
vi   viT5
bit np thu
n vic
ng mt tc ca
 m.
Ông Khut Ngc T10trnh bày:

 1990  2003 





 . 
C2 . 1993,  C2 T9(
T9 ). 














 
nh c chuyt c th   nh 



Nguy Trn Mnh C1
C2


T9.








, c


01 











. 







 18/10/1993 
T5











 (
 Nguyn Th C2



)  
. 
















18/10/1993 . 


, 

, 


, 
C2, T9L4 
. 
21


 18/12/1993; 









 18/12/1993  1,2 



 
.
T5





C2 T9




. 



T5


C2, 




, 










 . 






T5hay


 K1






T5
C2

T9. 
 T5

T9, C2






.
 02 


C2
P5 S


. 



 P5
C2





.
 


C2khu
n P, t, ngun gC2
anh My chng nhn quyn s dt. T 
s m i C2 dng th

 T5 




P5, H51987. 
C2 P5 P5H5




.












T5S












.

T5

, 



 




. 









, 
, 




, 






 c lp.
Ngày 20/7/2021, ông T10có bản t khai b sung th hin:
T9T5s i quan h 
T9T5 duy nht gT91 ln xu
T5 gp.
a nh ni dung vin kim
c v vi  nh s 458
nh s a UBND huyn P; T
khai chuyn quyn s dng, s ht np l c b 
22
T5nn vic chuyt giC2T9n
u in s ch vit, ch Nguyn Th C2T9
Nguyn Th T13 hi vit, t 
Ti giy chuy  t th        
Nguyn Th C2chuyNguyn Th T13t th
  vit ca  C2
 c vC2T13T5. Li khai cT5v vi
t ti thi di
Ông Nguyễn Đăng K1trnh bày:


1990-1999, 


 y 
nhim v cc hing. V vic chuyt ca 
Nguyn Th C2Trn Th T9, Trn Th T5th 
kh o UBND bt k nn vic chuyt
Trn Th T9Trn Th T5t c s
n v  ngh 
ngh  vng mt.
Ông Trn Mnh C1trnh bày:
  chc v Ch tch   t  -1999. Vic chuyn
t giC2vT9  
thng sao chp chng c 
y rng ch u chc danh, du c









t
   u c
Công ty cổ phn Ddo ông Trn Đức H7trnh bày:
 qun
T6H9
i vi tht s 101, 

 51, 

212,8m2  

khu H,
n P, tca v ch ti
 
b s ti
 n
 t khn hong sn xut. Vic hai
            T6  H9 c UBND
huyn Pcp giy chng nhn quyn s d     ngh  T6 
H9vn phi tip tc hi quyt c
c li quyt vng
mt.
Đại din theo ủy quyền của Ủy ban nhân dân xã Pdo ông Trần Trung K
:
V T5 ngh gii quyt tranh chi chiu vi
h y:
23
-  t tranh cht phn di
t thuc tht s 152-1, t b s 36;
-  t tranh cht phn di
t thuc tht s 101, t b s 51;
Tht s 152-1, t b s 36 (hay tha 101, t b s c
UBND huyn Pcp giy chng nhn quyn s d t s  
26/12/2001 cho h Nguyn Quang P3, s  cp giy chng nhn quyn
s dt: H01068
Hi u, chng c  vi
t gia C2L4T9
p c
liu, chng ch   y chuyt th 
C2n
kic vit giC2L4T9
 c b Trn Th T9np
tin; T khai chuyn dch quyn s hu, s dt np l c b 
18/12/1993 th hin vic chuyt giC2
T5
  qu 
th hi quynh giao mt ph tha
t s 152-1 (thu vi di b s 36 (hay tha
t s 101, t b s a ch: n P, t
Nguyn Th C2 hiC2c cp giy chng nhn quyn s
h         i dung ca h ng chuyn
t giC2T5 hin v  th 
ng giao dch i 4, .
, th tc UBND huyn Pcp giy chng nhn quyn s dt s
 Nguyn Quang P3i vi Tht s 152-
1, t b s 36 (hay tha 101, t b s nh ca
t.
Vic UBND huyn Pban nh hai sng nhau
 P3 C2 t
 thi gian   vic
C2 dng tht s 80, t bn
 s 36, dii n P, t(Th
gn tht cP3, nm ng quc l). Hi
C2chn s dng th.
Nay  ngh gii quyt v  nh ca
t.
Đại din theo y quyn ca Ủy ban nhân dân huyn P, tỉnh Phú Thọ trnh
bày:
V T5 ngh gii quyt tranh chi chiu vi
h y:
-  t tranh cht phn di
24
t thuc tht s 152-1, t b s 36;
-  t tranh cht phn di
t thuc tht s 101, t b s 51;
Tht s 152-1, t b s 36 (hay tha 101, t b s c
UBND huyn Pcp giy chng nhn quyn s d t s  
26/12/2001 cho h Nguyn Quang P3, s  cp giy chng nhn quyn
s dt: H01068
Hin nay, UBND huyn ch   u, chng
c y chuyt th C2
n kic vic mua
t giC2L4, T9 
c bTrn Th T9np tin; T khai chuyn dch quyn
s hu, s dt np l c b  hin vic chuyn
t giC2T5.
Trong   quUBND huyn P, qu
 hinh giao mt ph
tht s 152-1 (thu vi di b s 36 (hay
tht s 101, t b s a ch: n P, tcho
Nguyn Th C2g th hiC2c cp giy chng nhn quyn
s h i dung ca hng chuyn
t giC2T5 hin v  th 
ng giao dch i 4, .
, th tc UBND huyn Pcp giy chng nhn quyn s dt s
 Nguyn Quang P3i vi Tht s 152-
1, t b s 36 (hay tha 101, t b s nh ca
t. HiC2n s d
.
Vic UBND huyn P        
UBND huyn P
t th  vi
 a ch c th hin nay

Nay UBND huyn P ngh gi  nh
ct.
Ch Nguyn Th L3trnh bày:Hin nay ch i c
 phn Dt tranh chp). Ch ch n ca
  nh ch n tranh chp gi
T5vT6, H9. Ch  ngh   ngh  vng mt
ch
T14phiên tòa u khi kin phn
i v u c u khi ki
25
ngh T6, H9SH5120m2 c tha 
152-1, 

36 (Nay theo b 
101, 

51) n P, tC2





. N 
120m2 c
tha 152-1, 

 36 (Nay theo b 

101, 
 51) n P, t
C2i tr  c tha 80-2, 

36 (Nay theo bn
 t phn thuc 
95 96, 
51) khu
n P, t.
 m cu phn t.



,  H5 N ngh 




.



,  T7, anh H6 ngh p
nhu khi kin c
 , 










,



 


- p nhu khi kin c
NHẬN ĐỊNH CA TÒA ÁN:
[1] V t tng:
V thm quyi quyt: Tkhi ki
T5i ki ngh T6H9tr ln di
c tht s 152-1, t b s 36 hoc tha 101, t b s
a ch tht: n P, t 
  i b ki
H5Sp quyn s dnh ti
khou 26, m a khou 35 B lut t t
bng sa ch ti n P, tp thuc
thm quyn gii quyt cy theo
nh tm c khou 39 BLTTDS. B T6H9,
SH5.
V phm vi khi kin: Ti kii v n
  v : 




T6, H9SH5120m2 c tha 152-1, 

36
(Nay theo b 
101, 
51) 
P, huyn P, t C2 
.
Ti ph u khi ki ngh T6,
H9SH5 120m2 c tha 152-1, 

 36
26
(Nay theo b 
101, 
51) 
P, huyn P, t C2
. N 
120m2 c tha 152-1, 


36 (Nay theo b 
101, 
51) khu
n P, t 

C2i tr 120m2 
thuc tha 80-2, 

36 (Nay theo b t
phn thuc 
 95 96, 
 51) n P, t
Th.
Tht s 152-t s 80-y,
nh tu 188 B lut t t  gii quy
cu khi ki ngh T6, H9SH5120m2
c tha 152-1, 

 36 (Nay theo b 

101, 
51) n P, t

C2i v ngh
T6, H9SH5120m2 c tha 80-2, 


36 (Nay theo b t phn thuc 
6,

 51) n P, tu khi
kii quy T5
quyn khi kim quy i quy

[2] V ni dung:
- V ngun gc th t s 152-1, 

    
 101,

51) n P, t:
 T5cho rng:  18/10/1993, 
Nguyn Th C2( Nguyn Quang P3, 
 2002) 01 




120m2 (

90m2 

30m2 
), 


2 6m, 
20m. 
2, 

P3, 



B(

Q, 

P3. Di152-1, 

36 ( nay theo
b 
 101, 
51) n P, t
Th.  


C2 UBND huyn P(
huyn P) 
C2
 455 1987360m2 
. 
C2


 B240m2 
  T9    L4(ch  T9     ng chuyn

).
SH5Ncho rng: 





 P3, H5
  


1987 
P3, H5, 

 .    P3
 UBND huyn P

458/

360m2 







.
26/12/2001, UBND huyn P




27
P3, H5 152-1, 

 36, 

 1.336m2 (

300m2 

1.36m2 
).
u, chng c T5Snh ca
UBND huyn P, t v viC2P3. Hai quynh
u th hi i quynh
C2v c n 
P3c Nu.
   T5       t n  a
; 01 Quynh s a UBND huyn Pv vic
chuygiy chuyt th  
bn kic v vi khai thu thu
nh khai chuyn dch quyn s hu, s dt np l
c b   c b 
Chng nhn h s a UBND huyn
P. Anh Sgiao h p giy chng nhn quyn s dt cP3(b anh);
Giy chng nhn quyn s dt ci vi tht 151-1 (theo bn
 299) hay tht s 101 (Theo b  p giy
chng nhn quyn s dt (phT8; 
P4T6
H9p thu s dt cP3i vi tha
t 152-
HiC2C2 i con duy
nhM. Anh Mt hi c cp
giy chng nhn quyn s dC2ng t n
C2i naC2
   T9 T5c  
C2t ch.
T10a thm 1993-
nh:  ni dung vit trong n ki
 c v vi       nh s  
nh s a UBND huyn P; T khai
chuyn quyn s dng, s ht np l c b T5np
n vic chuyt giC2T9
mu in s ch vit, ch Nguyn Th C2T9Nguyn
Th T13 hi vit, t i giy chuyn
 t th         Nguyn Th C2chuyn
Nguyn Th T13t th 
 vit c C2 c
vC2T13T5a.
T5C2t ch  vit c
C2y t i ch  vit c
C2T13T5nh mi ch a
T13u, chng c  chng minh vic mua
t giC2T13i ch 
28
T13T5n tht cC2C2c cp
giy chng nhn quyn s dt, Giy chng nhn quyn s hC2ch
t ca n.
Trong Quy nh s    a UBND huyn Pv vic
chuy hin thu hi cC2di v N,
   giao ch  Trn Th Tuyt .1      a
 Trn Minh C3 t
u c th hin phT13c giao mt mt nm
ng quc l 2
 - V); hai m  hin, mt
mt na ti hin. HiC3 vic giao
c ph
 v 
  n ki    c v vi    
18/12/1993 th hin vi     C2v  L4(ch  T13  
T13th hiC2 v Quc l B
P3 B;  
P3t ding di
90m2... T5T10n phn ch vit trong ni dung ca
T10n. Phn
C2L4T13c
anh MT5T13T10T10
C2T13L4).
Trong h C2vL4
T13: php h sa chn
phn sa chT5T13, anh MT10n ch 
C2T13
 huyn P, t ng nhn h
 vi C2T13ng
thnh t Ch ch s
h mi khai ca 
huyn Pnh U  u, chng c 
hiC2c cp giy chng nhn quyn s h t c t
vy, hp  lp C2vL4
T13nh ct.
V li T5cho r C2n dic cp theo
quyt s a n Pti v 
khu vc Nmt phn diBt phn di
y lBv vii li khai cB
dy t, thu t vC2u,
chng c  chng minh viy chng nhn quyn s dt
i vi thC2 hin ngun g
         ng kin vi   t,
29
chuyt giC2vT13T5. Viuyn
  th chuyng t.
Chi cc thu khu vc L7 u, chng c
n nay Chi c h n t khai chuyn dch
quyn s hu, s dt np l c b  
thu l c b a ch c
ch  
i UBND huyn P ti th
 a ch c th n nay 
c quy t i giay.
t 152-a ch N, ng L5u:
c   a 
ng L5  t
khu vc tht s 152-ch s Hng L5. Hin
a danh ni vi tht 152-
P3t s H10 
 a.
n Pn tht s
152-1, t b s 36 (theo b a 101, t bn 
s 51 (theo b c UBND huyn Pcp giy chng
nhn quyn s dt s  Nguyn Quang
P3, s  cp giy chng nhn quyn s d, th tc
cp giy chng nhn quyn s di vi th
nh ct.
- V  dng th t:
 T5cho r       i qu  n di  t
C2 n diP3
T8   T8 T6 H9. Hi   T6  H9 

Anh Scho r dng tht 152-1 t 
200c cp giy chng nhn quyn s di vi tht
t phn phn dit thuc tht 152-1
 T8T8c cp giy chng nhn quyn s di vi phn
di      T8    T6  H9. Hi   T6 
H9
 hiP3c cp Giy chng nhn quyn s
di vi tht s 152-P3ng mt phn quyn s
dt thuc tht s 152-T8T8chuyng li
T6H9. HiT6H9 
ph
T10B1, anh Mt s 152-1
30
P3(b anh S) qu d
P3tip tc qu dng thP3t phn
quyn s dng tht s 152-1. Nay anh SH5i qu dng
phi ca tht 152-S t t c
cp giy chng nhn quyn s dn nay. L p vi li khai
ca anh Sp vu, chng c c.
T nhng nh   chp
nhu khi kin cT5 u khi kin c
T5p.
V  tng:
V  tng:
- V nh ti ch: Tng chnh ti
ch T5b u khi kiT5phi ch
T5 
- V n: Anh St nguyn ch 
 ngh T5phi tr l ngh 
ghi trong bn anh S 
V p v nh quyn s h
tranh chi vi v 
T5b u khi kiT5phi ch  m. Tuy
T5i cao tu ngh c min tin tm 
 T5T5c min tin tm 
i quyi vi tin tm 
V các lẽ trên;
QUYẾT ĐỊNH:
 u 73, 79 Lu
u 188,khom a khou m c
khou 39 B lut t t m a kho
khou 12 Ngh quyt s a y
ng v Quc hnh v mc thu, min gim, thu np, qu
d 
u khi kin cTrn Th T5.
V   tng:
V  tng: BuTrn Th T5phi ch 
thnh ti ch Trn Th T5 

31
V  Trn Th T5.
 c quyi h t 
  vng mc quy   t
c bc bt.
“Trường hp bản án được thi hành theo quy đnh tại Điều 2 Luật thi hành
án dân sự th người được thi hành án dân sự, người phải thi hành án dân sự
quyn tho thuận thi hành án, quyền yêu cầu thi hành án, t nguyn thi hành án
hoc b ng chế thi hành án theo quy đnh tại các Điều 6, 7, 7a 9 Luật Thi
hành án dân sự; Thi hiu thi hành án đưc thc hin theo quy định tại Điều 30
Luật Thi hành án Dân sự”.
Nơi nhận:
-;
- VKSND tnh, huyn;
- n;
-   
TM. HỘI ĐỒNG XÉT XỬ SƠ THẨM
THẨM PHÁN - CH TỌA PHIÊN T
Nguyễn Thanh Tùng
32
Tải về
Bản án số 77/2024/DS-PT Bản án số 77/2024/DS-PT

Quý khách vui lòng Đăng nhập tài khoản để tải file. Nếu chưa có tài khoản, Quý khách vui lòng đăng ký tại đây!

Bản án số 77/2024/DS-PT Bản án số 77/2024/DS-PT

Quý khách vui lòng Đăng nhập tài khoản để tải file. Nếu chưa có tài khoản, Quý khách vui lòng đăng ký tại đây!

Bản án/ Quyết định cùng đối tượng

Bản án cùng lĩnh vực

Bản án mới nhất